News & Views

 

As unicorns stumble, it’s time to shampoo the mane

 

By Alex Styles: 

The Unicorns. This once exclusive group of private start-ups valued north of USD 1bn has grown to 156 globally, fuelled by low interest rates and a warm rain of venture capital money. Now both funding and valuation have come under pressure. Not a single tech company or start-up went public in the first quarter of 2016. Large asset managers such as Fidelity, BlackRock or T Rowe Price have written down investments in big-brand start-ups such as Dropbox or Evernote. Others have faced so-called down-rounds, funding rounds with a lower valuation. The public offerings of both Box and Square came in at a lower valuation than previous private funding rounds.

There’s a variety of options for companies to deal with the increasing pressures on their equity valuation. The easiest: not to do equity funding at all. Spotify, for example, avoided a down-round at a lower valuation than the USD 8.5bn in June 2015 by raising USD 1bn in convertible debt in early 2016.

Faced with pressure on their valuation, management should ask: is our valuation under pressure because of our business model – or despite it? If revenues are growing, gross margins are close to industry standard and you’re profitable – or can at least show a clear path to profitability – the problem is unlikely to be the business model itself.

Rather, it is a matter of perception. And in the case of private companies, very often, a matter of transparency.

Transparency can be created and there are a number of simple tools.

  • Let founders and management speak at conferences. Not any conferences, but the right ones. At the right time.
  • Train management on messaging and get them to meet journalists.
  • Think about communicating financial results voluntarily. Not just to investors, but to the public.
  • Start behaving like a public company to increase confidence and trust. This is especially true in Europe, where both press and investors focus on profitability.

If, on the other hand, your revenues are declining, your gross margin is nowhere near industry standards and you are piling up loss after loss without a plan – well, maybe it’s time to stop worrying about valuations anyway.

And if you’re a unicorn, start looking for unicorn graveyards.

Share

Category