By Nick Bastin:
After two weeks of intense debate and talks spilling into the early hours of Saturday, world leaders reached an agreement in Paris, which President Obama has described as “the best chance we have to save the one planet we have.” Economist Nicholas Stern, in turn, described the talks as “the opening chapter of a new story of cleaner energy” and a “safer, more prosperous world.” From the UK’s perspective, Amber Rudd has claimed the nation is “absolutely committed” to the deal.
On Saturday, The Guardian summarised the key points that had been agreed upon. These points included an agreement to keep warming to below 2C, a target many didn’t think would be reached. Despite this, many have dismissed a lower 1.5C, target, as there are no measures for ‘hitting it’. Nations have also agreed to “achieve a balance between anthropogenic emissions and removals of sinks of greenhouse gases in the second half of this century.” Ensuring all countries review their emissions every five years had been a strongly contested point after China refused to budge and accept the agreement. However, the diplomats managed to come to a compromise on Saturday, with the first review under the new deal scheduled for 2023.
The question of loss, damage and finances was another point that caused much disagreement. The US, in particular, were worried about the risk of being liable for damage caused to at risk countries. The final deal has set a method for addressing the financial losses to countries threatened by climate change and affected by natural catastrophes, but keeps developed countries, including the US, safe from having to pay compensation for loss or damage. Instead the focus is on climate change mitigation with a minimum of $100bn of support each year from 2020, albeit in the non-legally binding part of the agreement.
Matt McGrath from the BBC, described the document as “carefully worded, balancing the rights of countries to develop, with the need to protect the planet.” McGrath’s article takes a positive view on the “historic” talks. Flexibility was a key word in the agreement, which gives developing nations time to come into the system when ready. One major weakness of the agreement, however, was its failure to set fines or penalties. Negotiators also agreed that the deal will be overseen by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change.
The FT focused on the crucial role of French Foreign Minister and Summit President Laurent Fabius. With the talks being extended into Saturday, Mr Fabius was under pressure to sort an agreement. It was Nicaragua who surprised many by seeking a technical delay as they wanted their voice to be heard, dampening hope among negotiators. Mr Fabius cut short the Nicaraguan delegates, and quickly announced “I am looking at the room, I see the reaction is positive, the Paris climate accord is accepted!” Laurent’s work was applauded by many nations with prominent Indian delegate Prakash Javadekar saying: “I must congratulate you [Mr Fabius], your patience.”
The Independent on Sunday’s Caroline Mortimer focused on the words of professor and environmental activist James Hansen, who claimed that “there is no action, just promises” in the deal. Mr Hansen, who is known as the “father of climate change awareness”, claimed the agreement was nothing but a “fraud” and “worthless words.”
The New York Times’s article on Sunday “A Signal to Industry to Go Green in an Era of Carbon Reduction” looks at the impact the deal will have on industries. The piece claims banks and investment funds will now shift from oil and gas to renewables, while utilities will move away from their reliance on coal. One senior executive, who works for a utility company with coal assets but refused to be identified by name, said: “We are not too worried to be honest, it does not change much right now.”
But the climate conference did not only receive attention from the media. It was obvious that today’s biggest business leaders were keeping a close eye on Paris. BP tweeted on Saturday describing the agreement as a “landmark climate change deal” promising to be part of the solution. Yet, as noted by The New York Times, the carbon taxing or carbon pricing that many were hoping would become mandatory with the agreement had been left out. Carbon taxing was seen as crucial to curb climate change by many energy experts. But still, the influence of the talks can already be seen, with Ford announcing that by 2020 they would invest $4.5 billion in new electrical vehicles.
The FT’s opinion piece on Sunday, written by economist Nicholas Stern, calls for public-private collaboration in order to reach set goals. Stern highlights the need and challenge for nations to increase investment in cleaner technology. Stern focuses on the role development banks such as The World Bank will now play, as they must make finance available to developing nations. Stern further remarks that one major responsibility now falls on nation states and their governments as they strive to eliminate hundreds of billions of dollars of direct subsidies for fossil fuel and redirect the money to clean energy. The Sunday Times agreed with the increasing responsibility that national governments now have, as Jonathan Leake wrote that Britain’s carbon budgets must now be much tougher to achieve the 1.5C target.