News & Views

 

COP21 Week 2 – 8th – 11th December

 

By Nick Bastin:

The last few days of COP21 have been marked by disagreements in efforts to reach a final proposal, and this has resulted in talks being extended until Saturday.

On Tuesday, 79 countries from Africa, the Caribbean and the Pacific Islands joined 28 European countries to form an alliance to push for an agreement on some of the most disputed topics. The group was focused on making the agreement legally binding, setting a clear, long-term goal on global warming based on scientific advice. This would introduce a way of reviewing countries’ emissions every five years and creating an international system for tracking progress on meeting carbon goals. The alliance has been coined ‘the ambition coalition’.

Tony de Brum, Foreign Minister of the Marshall Islands, described the alliance as acting as a “mosquito fleet”, sending envoys to various parties to “bite them in a nice way”. He said he had personally requested meetings with Australia, Canada and India, though no one in the group has tried to contact with China.

China has continued to be a contentious point of discussion in the latter stages of meeting: the FT reported that one negotiator had accused Chinese officials of weakening efforts to establish a common system for countries to report their emission levels to the UN. Another negotiator claimed Chinese delegates were also resisting the five yearly reviews proposed by the other countries.

On Wednesday, the FT reported the US had also joined the alliance. Todd Stern, part of the US team in Paris said “This is our moment and we need to make it count”. Norway, Mexico and Colombia have also offered their support to the group. However, the US refuse to make pollution targets internationally binding, due to the legal limits of Obama’s authority and the fact that many other nations will resist the idea.

India’s Environment Minister Prakash Java highlighted on Wednesday that: “The next 48 hours will be all hard and real negotiations, but we will ensure that the world has a good outcome from Paris.”

John Kerry surprised many spectators, announcing that by 2020 the US would double the $430m it provided in 2014 to help those nations most at risk of climate change. The donation comes after India’s Environment Minister Prakash Javadekar told reporters that developed countries “have not made much headway” towards providing finance to developing nations. He further questioned a recent OECD study that concluded as much as $62bn in funding from public and private sources was delivered in 2014. Upon hearing of the USA’s increased donation, he said that if countries want to update their pledges they were free to do so, however, it should be “a voluntary thing”.

The French hosts released another draft agreement on Wednesday. One of the major talking points was the call from over 100 nations to limit warming to 1.5C. Anote Tong, President of Kiribati in the Pacific told the Guardian, “I’ve always said we need to come away from Paris with a deal that would ensure the survival of people. Nobody left behind – that’s the mission all along.”

However, not everyone is happy with the draft. The European Union is against leaving out any text in reference to emissions from shipping and aviation. They described it as an “unacceptable level of low ambition”. While India’s Prakash Javadekar said he had no problem with a 1.5C target, once developed countries make the additional emissions cuts that would be required to meet it.

The Telegraph featured an article written by Arun Jaitley, India’s Minister of Finance on Wednesday, titled ‘India can’t go it alone on climate change’. Mr Jaitley writes about how India’s climate change commitments have been designed to address environmental concerns while also enabling the nation to meet the growth levels needed for development. Mr Jaitley highlights efforts made by India such as cutting the petroleum subsidy by about 26 percent and introducing a carbon tax on gasoline and diesel. He concludes by describing India’s approach as entrenched in a vision of equity, inspired by Mahatma Gandhi’s famous quote: “Earth has enough resources to meet people’s needs, but will never have enough to satisfy people’s greed.” Mr Jaitley concludes saying “I am hoping for an outcome from the 2015 Paris Climate Conference which allows for such equitable sharing of responsibilities and will therefore enable more of us to do more to tackle climate change.”

Nick Dearden, director of Global Justice Now, wrote a scathing article in the Independent on Wednesday on developed nations’ role in Paris and that rich countries are outsourcing their problems to the poorest nations. Dearden believes that ‘net reductions’ in emissions can mean wealthy, developed country’s emissions will rise, as long as pollution is outsourced to the Global South.

The French presented an updated draft agreement on Thursday night. The latest proposal has been shorted to 27 pages, and had the amount of issues yet to be agreed upon cut from 900 to roughly 50.

French Foreign Minister Laurent Fabius has said, “I will not present the text Friday evening, as I had thought, but Saturday morning. There is still work to do. Things are going in the right direction.”

The wording of the agreement has been a major obstacle to its finalisation. The US have been insistent that words about loss and damage should not suggest liability or compensation or open any possibility of legal action against US companies.

The most recent draft released late on Thursday night says nations should stick to a previously agreed goal to keep warming below 2C, and “pursue efforts” to prevent temperatures rising above 1.5C.

The FT highlights that nations continue in their struggle to find common ground with China. The proposal to have all nations meet every 5 years and re discuss agreements made, is something China is refusing to accept. “Without the five-year cycles, the agreement is meaningless” according to the EU’s climate commissioner Miguel Arias Cañete. China’s representative Gao Feng, said Beijing would not be able to change its climate plans for at least another 15 years.

From a business perspective, optimism weakened, as parts of the agreement encouraging carbon pricing are likely be removed. “We do not think it is politically feasible to get that [carbon pricing] now,” said Edward Cameron from We Mean Business, that consists of a group corporations members including Google and General Electric.

Share

Category