Why Frankfurt will benefit from Brexit – A somewhat biased view

 

Share

When your city features in the New York Times‘ annual list of “52 Places to Go”, surely it must be a hip and happening place. That’s certainly what most “Frankfurters” thought in 2014, when their city of 715,000 made it into the top ranks of that very list (Yorkshire was also on it, but that’s another story altogether). Many non-Frankfurters were equally surprised, however – not least since the NYT’s assessment of Frankfurt’s hipness appeared to be largely based on a few cool night spots having sprung up recently in the city’s (otherwise still grubby) red-light district. No doubt, Frankfurt’s image as a drab, boring and provincial place is hard to shake off.

Whether or not Frankfurt is attractive is once again hotly debated in the aftermath of the recent Brexit vote. The city is actively positioning itself as an alternative to London for banks and bankers in search of a new hub should London’s star as a financial centre wane in the wake of Brexit. Frankfurt is widely seen as the biggest winner among European cities to benefit, leading rivals such as Paris or Amsterdam by a substantial margin in most surveys.

You wouldn’t see that mirrored much in the local media, however. Reflecting perhaps a characteristic degree of German pragmatism, local politics and media have been less than enthusiastic about Frankfurt’s prospects to replace London as Europe’s capital of finance. “London, Frankfurt and the Lack of Metropolitan Flair” is how national daily Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung put it earlier this month, where it quoted Tarek Al-Wazir, Economy Minister of the state of Hesse in which Frankfurt is located, as saying: “I don’t expect 10,000 people with their suitcases packed to arrive in Frankfurt the day after tomorrow.”

So how does Frankfurt stack up in the race against London? Well, at least in this author’s largely subjective view, quite well.

The biggest reason for why Frankfurt is set to benefit from Brexit is that it is already quite a dominant force in global finance. The most obvious sign of that is the gleaming ECB towers overlooking the east side of the city. Not only does the ECB set monetary policy for the entire euro zone, it also recently became the bloc’s top banking regulator. That gives Frankfurt a natural edge over most other cities jostling to replace London as Europe’s financial center.

Even beyond the obvious, there is ample evidence that Frankfurt has what it takes to outdo its rivals in the race to attract London’s legions of bankers. Consider these factors:

Quality of Life. Frankfurt ranks 7th in the annual Mercer quality of living survey of international cities. London? Nowhere near the top 30 even. The Economist Intelligence Unit, in its just-released liveability ranking of cities around the globe, has Frankfurt in 20th place. London is far behind at number 53.

Low cost of living. London consumer prices on average are some 10% higher than in Frankfurt. Include rent, and the premium is almost 45%.

Availability of office space. Recent studies claim more than 10% of office space in Frankfurt is unoccupied. And it’s relatively cheap: Office rents are merely about a quarter of those in London. A study by EY says 72% of real estate professionals see Frankfurt as the biggest winner of a Brexit. If true, that will translate into rising rents – quickly. Better move fast to claim that new office space on the banks of the river Main.

Culture and Language. Frankfurt boasts continental Europe’s largest English-language theatre,English is widely spoken and understood by almost everyone in Frankfurt. You can get pretty much everything you need without ever having to speak a word of German. Ever tried the same with German in London?

Gastronomy. Yes, gastronomy. Frankfurt has nine Michelin-starred restaurants. That’s far fewer in absolute terms than London – but about twice as many on a per-capita basis. And very few of them will feature Bratwurst or Sauerkraut.

Proximity to nature. OK, Frankfurt may not be the most metropolitan city in the world. But it certainly is one of the greenest. For that much-needed stroll to help digest your Michelin-starred meal, Frankfurt (named “European City of Trees” in 2014) boasts the country’s biggest city forest.

No doubt are numerous other reasons for why Frankfurt stands to benefit from Brexit. Of course, this author’s view may be somewhat biased – being a native can do that to you. So here’s looking at my London-based colleagues to challenge my analysis.

Knut Engelmann

Knut Engelmann

More posts

Categories